Tokio Async Code Review

Review Workflow

1. Check Cargo.toml — Note tokio feature flags (full, rt-multi-thread, macros, sync, etc.). Missing features cause confusing compile errors.
2. Check runtime setup — Is #[tokio::main] or manual runtime construction used? Multi-thread vs current-thread?
3. Scan for blocking — Search for std::fs, std::net, std::thread::sleep, CPU-heavy loops in async functions.
4. Check channel usage — Match channel type to communication pattern (mpsc, broadcast, oneshot, watch).
5. Check sync primitives — Verify correct mutex type, proper guard lifetimes, no deadlock potential.

Output Format

Report findings as:

[FILE:LINE] ISSUE_TITLE
Severity: Critical | Major | Minor | Informational
Description of the issue and why it matters.

Quick Reference

Review Checklist

Runtime Configuration

• Tokio features in Cargo.toml match actual usage
• Runtime flavor matches workload (multi_thread for I/O-bound, current_thread for simpler cases)
• #[tokio::test] used for async tests (not manual runtime construction)
• Worker thread count configured appropriately for production

Task Management

• spawn return values (JoinHandle) are tracked, not silently dropped
• spawn_blocking used for CPU-heavy or synchronous I/O operations
• Tasks respect cancellation (via CancellationToken, select!, or shutdown channels)
• JoinError (task panic or cancellation) is handled, not just unwrapped
• tokio::select! branches are cancellation-safe

Sync Primitives

• tokio::sync::Mutex used when lock is held across .await; std::sync::Mutex for short non-async sections
• No mutex guard held across await points (deadlock risk)
• Semaphore used for limiting concurrent operations (not ad-hoc counters)
• RwLock used when read-heavy workload (many readers, infrequent writes)
• Notify used for simple signaling (not channel overhead)

Channels

• Channel type matches pattern: mpsc for back-pressure, broadcast for fan-out, oneshot for request-response, watch for latest-value
• Bounded channels have appropriate capacity (not too small = deadlock, not too large = memory)
• SendError / RecvError handled (indicates other side dropped)
• Broadcast Lagged errors handled (receiver fell behind)
• Channel senders dropped when done to signal completion to receivers

Timer and Sleep

• tokio::time::sleep used instead of std::thread::sleep
• tokio::time::timeout wraps operations that could hang
• tokio::time::interval used correctly (.tick().await for periodic work)

Severity Calibration

Critical

• Blocking I/O (std::fs::read, std::net::TcpStream) in async context without spawn_blocking
• Mutex guard held across .await point (deadlock potential)
• std::thread::sleep in async function (blocks runtime thread)
• Unbounded channel where back-pressure is needed (OOM risk)

Major

• JoinHandle silently dropped (lost errors, zombie tasks)
• Missing select! cancellation safety consideration
• Wrong mutex type (std vs tokio) for the use case
• Missing timeout on network/external operations

Minor

• tokio::spawn for trivially small async blocks (overhead > benefit)
• Overly large channel buffer without justification
• Manual runtime construction where #[tokio::main] suffices
• std::sync::Mutex where contention is high enough to benefit from tokio's async mutex

Informational

• Suggestions to use tokio-util utilities (e.g., CancellationToken)
• Tower middleware patterns for service composition
• Structured concurrency with JoinSet

Valid Patterns (Do NOT Flag)

• std::sync::Mutex for short critical sections — tokio docs recommend this when no .await is inside the lock
• tokio::spawn without explicit join — Valid for background tasks with proper shutdown signaling
• Unbuffered channel capacity of 1 — Valid for synchronization barriers
• #[tokio::main(flavor = "current_thread")] in simple binaries — Not every app needs multi-thread runtime
• clone() on Arc<T> before spawn — Required for moving into tasks, not unnecessary cloning
• Large broadcast channel capacity — Valid when lagged errors are expensive (event sourcing)

Before Submitting Findings

Load and follow beagle-rust:review-verification-protocol before reporting any issue.