技术栈评估
tech-stack-evaluator
by alirezarezvani
对比框架、数据库和云服务,结合 5 年 TCO、安全风险、生态活力与迁移复杂度做量化评估,适合技术选型、栈升级和替换路线决策。
帮你系统比较技术栈优劣,不只看功能,还把TCO、安全性和生态健康度一起量化,选型和迁移决策更稳。
安装
claude skill add --url github.com/alirezarezvani/claude-skills/tree/main/engineering-team/tech-stack-evaluator文档
Technology Stack Evaluator
Evaluate and compare technologies, frameworks, and cloud providers with data-driven analysis and actionable recommendations.
Table of Contents
Capabilities
| Capability | Description |
|---|---|
| Technology Comparison | Compare frameworks and libraries with weighted scoring |
| TCO Analysis | Calculate 5-year total cost including hidden costs |
| Ecosystem Health | Assess GitHub metrics, npm adoption, community strength |
| Security Assessment | Evaluate vulnerabilities and compliance readiness |
| Migration Analysis | Estimate effort, risks, and timeline for migrations |
| Cloud Comparison | Compare AWS, Azure, GCP for specific workloads |
Quick Start
Compare Two Technologies
Compare React vs Vue for a SaaS dashboard.
Priorities: developer productivity (40%), ecosystem (30%), performance (30%).
Calculate TCO
Calculate 5-year TCO for Next.js on Vercel.
Team: 8 developers. Hosting: $2500/month. Growth: 40%/year.
Assess Migration
Evaluate migrating from Angular.js to React.
Codebase: 50,000 lines, 200 components. Team: 6 developers.
Input Formats
The evaluator accepts three input formats:
Text - Natural language queries
Compare PostgreSQL vs MongoDB for our e-commerce platform.
YAML - Structured input for automation
comparison:
technologies: ["React", "Vue"]
use_case: "SaaS dashboard"
weights:
ecosystem: 30
performance: 25
developer_experience: 45
JSON - Programmatic integration
{
"technologies": ["React", "Vue"],
"use_case": "SaaS dashboard"
}
Analysis Types
Quick Comparison (200-300 tokens)
- Weighted scores and recommendation
- Top 3 decision factors
- Confidence level
Standard Analysis (500-800 tokens)
- Comparison matrix
- TCO overview
- Security summary
Full Report (1200-1500 tokens)
- All metrics and calculations
- Migration analysis
- Detailed recommendations
Scripts
stack_comparator.py
Compare technologies with customizable weighted criteria.
python scripts/stack_comparator.py --help
tco_calculator.py
Calculate total cost of ownership over multi-year projections.
python scripts/tco_calculator.py --input assets/sample_input_tco.json
ecosystem_analyzer.py
Analyze ecosystem health from GitHub, npm, and community metrics.
python scripts/ecosystem_analyzer.py --technology react
security_assessor.py
Evaluate security posture and compliance readiness.
python scripts/security_assessor.py --technology express --compliance soc2,gdpr
migration_analyzer.py
Estimate migration complexity, effort, and risks.
python scripts/migration_analyzer.py --from angular-1.x --to react
References
| Document | Content |
|---|---|
references/metrics.md | Detailed scoring algorithms and calculation formulas |
references/examples.md | Input/output examples for all analysis types |
references/workflows.md | Step-by-step evaluation workflows |
Confidence Levels
| Level | Score | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| High | 80-100% | Clear winner, strong data |
| Medium | 50-79% | Trade-offs present, moderate uncertainty |
| Low | < 50% | Close call, limited data |
When to Use
- Comparing frontend/backend frameworks for new projects
- Evaluating cloud providers for specific workloads
- Planning technology migrations with risk assessment
- Calculating build vs. buy decisions with TCO
- Assessing open-source library viability
When NOT to Use
- Trivial decisions between similar tools (use team preference)
- Mandated technology choices (decision already made)
- Emergency production issues (use monitoring tools)
相关 Skills
资深架构师
by alirezarezvani
适合系统设计评审、ADR记录和扩展性规划,分析依赖与耦合,权衡单体或微服务、数据库与技术栈选型,并输出Mermaid、PlantUML、ASCII架构图。
✎ 搞系统设计、技术选型和扩展规划时,用它能更快理清架构决策与依赖关系,还能直接产出 Mermaid/PlantUML 图,方案讨论效率很高。
迁移架构师
by alirezarezvani
为数据库、API 与基础设施迁移制定分阶段零停机方案,提前校验兼容性与风险,生成回滚策略、验证关卡和时间线,适合复杂系统平滑切换。
✎ 做数据库与存储迁移时,用它统一梳理表结构和数据搬迁流程,架构视角更完整,复杂迁移也更稳。
资深数据工程师
by alirezarezvani
聚焦生产级数据工程,覆盖 ETL/ELT、批处理与流式管道、数据建模、Airflow/dbt/Spark 优化和数据质量治理,适合设计数据架构、搭建现代数据栈与排查性能问题。
✎ 复杂数据管道、ETL/ELT 和治理难题交给它,凭 Spark、Airflow、dbt 等现代数据栈经验,能更稳地搭起可扩展的数据基础设施。
相关 MCP 服务
PostgreSQL 数据库
编辑精选by Anthropic
PostgreSQL 是让 Claude 直接查询和管理你的数据库的 MCP 服务器。
✎ 这个服务器解决了开发者需要手动编写 SQL 查询的痛点,特别适合数据分析师或后端开发者快速探索数据库结构。不过,由于是参考实现,生产环境使用前务必评估安全风险,别指望它能处理复杂事务。
SQLite 数据库
编辑精选by Anthropic
SQLite 是让 AI 直接查询本地数据库进行数据分析的 MCP 服务器。
✎ 这个服务器解决了 AI 无法直接访问 SQLite 数据库的问题,适合需要快速分析本地数据集的开发者。不过,作为参考实现,它可能缺乏生产级的安全特性,建议在受控环境中使用。
Firecrawl 智能爬虫
编辑精选by Firecrawl
Firecrawl 是让 AI 直接抓取网页并提取结构化数据的 MCP 服务器。
✎ 它解决了手动写爬虫的麻烦,让 Claude 能直接访问动态网页内容。最适合需要实时数据的研究者或开发者,比如监控竞品价格或抓取新闻。但要注意,它依赖第三方 API,可能涉及隐私和成本问题。